DVD Encoding
DVD-Video can be encoded to either MPEG-1 or
MPEG-2, as summarised in the table below:
| |
MPEG-2 |
MPEG-1 |
| PAL/SECAM resolutions |
720 x 576
704 x 576
352 x 576
352 x 288 |
352 x 576
352 x 288 |
| NTSC resolutions |
720 x 480
704 x 480
352 x 480
352 x 240 |
352 x 480
351 x 240 |
| Variable Bit Rate (VBR), Constant Bit Rate (CBR) |
VBR or CBR |
CBR |
| PAL/SECAM frame rate |
25fps |
| NTSC frame rate |
24 or 30fps |
Variable bit rate (VBR) encoding allows higher image quality
at a lower average bit rate by using more data to encode those parts of
a video sequence which are more complex and do not compress well. Using
constant bit rate (CBR) encoding, the video data rate must be high enough
to encode all the video well.
Early DVD-ROM drives used one of two strategies
for delivering MPEG-2 video. Some used a technique called analogue overlay,
also referred to as video overlay or simply overlay. Others employed the
VGA-inlay approach, sometimes referred to as VideoInlay. Both methods
display video in a window or at full screen, but they take different approaches.
VideoInlay relies on the PC's graphics adapter to scale the video and
output it to a monitor. Overlay boards, by contrast, provide their own
hardware scaling and output the video themselves, overlaying it with graphics
output passed through from the VGA card. With these boards, an included
cable runs from the VGA connect of the display adapter to an input on
the bracket of the decoder board.
The major drawback of the VGA-inlay approach is the load
it places on a system. While pushing 30 frames of video per second might
not saturate the PCI bus, it does keep bus utilisation high. When playing
scenes encoded at a high bit rate, VGA-inlay boards can overwhelm older,
slower display adapters with too much data, requiring a reduction in horizontal
resolution to produce an acceptable picture.
Requiring a bit more work to install and configure than
VGA-inlay boards, video-overlay boards demand less of a system and tolerate
a wider variety of hardware. While video output may be less sharp than
that displayed by VGA-inlay boards, the video-overlay approach has the
advantage of being capable of decent performance with just about any video
card.
The original audio encoding format specification
for European DVD discs was MPEG-2 surround sound, creating a degree of
confusion since Dolby Digital AC3 had become established as a mainstream
format with the rest of the DVD world. The situation was clarified in
January 1998 when the DVD Forum agreed on a dual standard which allowed
both encoding formats.
The launch of DVD-Video has been severely
impacted by technical issues, and not least those concerning encryption.
DVD-Video players finally came to market in Japan in November 1996 and
in the USA in March 1997. In Europe, the major launch was delayed until
the autumn of 1998.
DVD Encryption
By the end of 2000, there were six forms of DVD copy protection in use
or planned:
- Analogue CPS (Macrovision): The general term is APS
(Analogue Protection System). The system is designed to prevent copying
onto consumer VCRs.
The producer of the disc decides what amount of copy protection to enable
and then pays Macrovision royalties accordingly. Just as with videotapes,
some DVDs are Macrovision-protected and some aren't.
- CGMS: This is a 'serial' copy generation management
system (SCMS)
designed to prevent copies or copies of copies. The CGMS information
is embedded in the outgoing video signal. For CGMS to work, the equipment
making the copy must recognise and respect the CGMS.
- CSS: 'Content Scrambling System' is a form of data
encryption to discourage reading media files directly from the disc.
The system requires that DVD-ROM drives and video decoder hardware or
software incorporate a decryption circuit that decodes data before displaying
it.
- CPPM: 'Content Protection for Pre-recorded Media' replaces
CSS for DVD-Audio. Keys are stored in the lead-in area, but there are
no title keys in the sector headers. The disc key is replaced by an
"album identifier."
- CPRM: The 'Content Protection for Recordable Media'
mechanism - supported by all DVD recorders released after 1999 - ties
a recording to the media on which it is recorded. It associates an encryption
code with the unique 64-bit disc ID etched into the BCA of blank recordable
DVDs when protected content is recorded onto the disc.
- DTCP: 'Digital Transmission Content Protection' is
the frontrunner of a number of 'digital copy protection systems' (DCPS)
under consideration. A draft proposal (called the 5CP, for 'five-company
proposal') was made by Intel, Sony, Hitachi, Matsushita, and Toshiba
in February 1998 which addresses digital connections between components
via IEEE 1394. Content is marked with standard CGMS flags of 'copy never'
or 'copy once'. Devices that are digitally connected, such as a DVD
player and a digital TV, will exchange keys and authentication certificates
to establish a channel. Products using DTCP are not expected before
2001 at the earliest.
Regional coding
Motion picture studios want to control the home release of
movies in different countries because cinema releases aren't simultaneous
(a movie may come out on video in the U.S. when it's just hitting screens
in Europe). Also, studios sell distribution rights to different foreign
distributors and would like to guarantee an exclusive market. Therefore
they have required that the DVD standard include codes that can be used
to prevent playback of certain discs in certain geographical regions.
Each player is given a code for the region in which it's sold. The player
will refuse to play discs that are not allowed in that region. This means
that discs bought in one country may not play on players bought in another
country.
Regional codes are entirely optional for the maker of
a disc. Discs without codes will play on any player in any country. It's
not an encryption system, it's just one byte of information on the disc,
which recognises eight different DVD worldwide regions, that the player
checks:
| Region 1 |
USA, Canada, U.S. Territories |
| Region 2 |
Japan, Europe, South Africa, and Middle East
(including Egypt) |
| Region 3 |
Southeast Asia and East Asia (including Hong
Kong) |
| Region 4 |
Australia, New Zealand, Pacific Islands, Central
America, Mexico, South America, and the Caribbean |
| Region 5 |
Eastern Europe (former Soviet Union), Indian
subcontinent, Africa, North Korea, and Mongolia |
| Region 6 |
China |
| Region 7 |
Reserved |
| Region 8 |
Special international venues (airplanes, cruise
ships, etc.) |
Region-2 coding standards proved more complicated to finalise
than was originally expected, due to huge variations in censorship laws
and the number of different languages spoken across the region, and was
one of the main reasons for DVD taking so long to become established.
It's impossible to include films coded for every country in Region-2 on
a single disc. This led the DVDF to split the region into several sub-regions,
and this, in turn, caused delays in the availability of Region-2 discs.
By the autumn of 1998 barely a dozen Region-2 discs had been released,
compared to the hundreds of titles available in the US. This situation
led to many companies selling DVD players that had been reconfigured to
play discs from any region.
With hindsight, the attempt at regional segregation was
probably doomed to failure from the very start. The games console manufacturers
(Nintendo, Sega and Sony) have been trying to stop owners from playing
games imported from other countries for several years now. Generally,
whenever such regional standards were implemented, it only took someone
a few weeks to work out a way around it, whether it be a cartridge adapter
or a modification to the machine itself. In real terms, all regional DVD
coding has cost the DVD Forum a lot of money, delayed market up-take and
allowed third-party companies to make a great deal of money bypassing
it.
Ultimately, DVD will prevail as there's simply far too
much heavyweight support behind it. In the US, even the die-hard LaserDisc
collectors are being forced to adopt DVD as the movie studios cut down
their LaserDisc production and ramp up their DVD output. With the increasing
availability of DVD-ROM drives in notebook PCs and the availability of
software-based MPEG-2 decoders capable of delivering significantly better
results than older hardware-based solutions, it appears likely that DVD
will make significant market inroads in the second half of 1998.
BAckup your DVD's with DVD X Copy